Reading Below the Waterline

A Method for Transformational Bible Study

The Problem: Why Bible Study Doesn’t Always Change Us

You know the feeling. You read your Bible, you understand what it says, you even know what you should do differently. But a week later—or even a day later—you’re back to the same patterns. The same anxieties. The same responses. The same struggles.

Why doesn’t Bible study produce the lasting change Scripture promises?

The answer lies in what we’re addressing—or more accurately, what we’re not addressing.

The Iceberg Principle

Above the Waterline (Visible – 10%):

• Behaviors and actions
• Emotions and feelings
• Conscious thoughts
• Circumstances we face

Below the Waterline (Hidden – 90%):

• Unconscious beliefs about how life works
• Deep purposes that drive us without our awareness
• Mental programming accumulated over years
• Core longings for significance and security
• Functional idols—what we actually trust for life

Most Bible study operates exclusively above the waterline. We ask: What does this passage mean? What happened in this story? What should I do differently? These aren’t bad questions—they’re essential. But when we stop here, we miss Scripture’s primary target: what operates beneath the surface.

Biblical Foundation: Proverbs 20:5

“The purpose in a man’s heart is like deep water, but a man of understanding will draw it out.” (Proverbs 20:5)

This ancient wisdom, written under the Spirit’s inspiration, reveals a profound truth: what drives us operates beneath conscious awareness like water in a deep well—hidden, inaccessible without intentional effort, often unknown even to ourselves.

Scripture consistently teaches this reality:

• Proverbs 4:23 – “Above all else, guard your heart, for everything you do flows from it”
• Jeremiah 17:9 – “The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?”
• Mark 7:21-23 – “For from within, out of the heart of man, come evil thoughts, sexual immorality, theft, murder…”
• Hebrews 4:12 – “The word of God is living and active, sharper than any two-edged sword, piercing to the division of soul and of spirit…discerning the thoughts and intentions of the heart”

We don’t naturally know what drives us. The heart’s deepest purposes require intentional “drawing out” through wisdom, discernment, and the Spirit’s illumination.

Understanding Your Heart: The New Covenant Reality

Before we go further, we need theological precision about what’s happening “below the waterline.”

For Unbelievers:
The heart itself is corrupted (heart of stone, Ezekiel 36:26), fundamentally directed away from God, trusting functional idols for significance and security. What’s below the waterline reveals actual heart-level idolatry.

For Believers:
The New Covenant gives you a new heart of flesh (Ezekiel 36:26; 2 Corinthians 5:17). If you’re in Christ, your heart is fundamentally oriented toward God and genuinely desires dependence on Him. You have a new heart. You truly want God.

However, Scripture also speaks of “the flesh”—the remaining corruption and old programming formed when the Sinful Heart ruled. What’s below the waterline for believers is not heart-level corruption but flesh patterns—unconscious beliefs and mental programming that contradict what your new heart actually desires.

This distinction matters: Sanctification isn’t about changing your heart (the New Covenant already did that). It’s about aligning your soul—your thinking, choosing, and living—with what your new heart already knows and desires.

The struggle you feel isn’t evidence of a corrupt heart. It’s the tension between your new heart (which truly wants God) and remaining flesh (which operates on old programming). And your new heart will win.

The Four-Step Method

The “Reading Below the Waterline” method helps you cooperate with the Spirit’s work by exposing and transforming what operates beneath conscious awareness. It consists of four progressive steps:

Step 1: Ask the Heart Question

Objective: Move from “What does this mean?” to “What does this reveal below the waterline?”

Traditional Bible study asks informational questions. This step asks deeper questions:

• What unconscious beliefs appear in this passage?
• What functional idols (false sources of life) do people trust here?
• What false sources of significance or security surface?
• Where do I see my own flesh patterns reflected in this text?

Example: Reading James 4:1-3 (“What causes quarrels and fights among you?”), we don’t stop at “Fighting is wrong.” We ask: “What does this reveal about what we’re trusting for life besides God? The passage shows people fighting because their ‘passions’ have become functional gods—they’re trusting the fulfillment of desires to give them life.”

Step 2: Expose the Counterfeit

Objective: Identify the false sources of significance and security—the functional idols that promise life but can’t deliver.

A functional idol is anything the flesh believes it must have for significance or security. Common counterfeits include:

• Approval – Needing people to think well of you
• Control – Needing circumstances to go according to your plan
• Comfort – Needing to avoid pain and difficulty
• Success – Needing achievement to matter
• Security – Needing financial stability to feel safe
• Relationships – Needing a person’s love to be complete

These aren’t bad things—they become functional idols when the flesh elevates them to non-negotiable demands, trusting them instead of God.

Key questions:

• What counterfeit source of life appears in this passage?
• How does the passage expose the counterfeit’s futility?
• What is my flesh’s version of this functional idol?

Remember: For believers, these are flesh patterns, not heart-level corruption. Your new heart truly wants to depend on God; the flesh just operates on old programming.

Step 3: Embrace the Gospel

Objective: Connect every passage to Christ and gospel truth, allowing the gospel to address what the flesh believes.

All Scripture points to Christ (Luke 24:27). Every functional idol Scripture exposes, the gospel addresses. This step asks:

• How does this passage point to Christ?
• What gospel truth addresses the flesh’s lie exposed in Steps 1-2?
• How is Christ superior to the counterfeit?

Gospel truths that transform:

1. Secure Identity – My worth is established by Christ’s work, not my performance (Romans 8:1, 38-39)
2. Satisfied Longings – Christ is my ultimate satisfaction; in Him I have everything I need (John 4:14; 2 Peter 1:3)
3. Perfect Acceptance – I’m fully accepted in Christ based on His righteousness (Romans 5:1-2; Ephesians 1:6)
4. True Security – God holds me securely; nothing can separate me from His love (Romans 8:31-39)
5. Transforming Power – The Spirit transforms me; I can’t, but He can (2 Corinthians 3:18; Philippians 2:13)

Critical truth: If you’re in Christ, your new heart already knows these truths and treasures Christ. The Spirit is renewing your mind to align with what your heart already desires.

Step 4: Apply Below the Waterline

Objective: Move beyond behavioral modification to genuine transformation by addressing beliefs, desires, and dependence.

Traditional application targets behavior: I should do X, I should stop doing Y. Below-the-waterline application addresses three deeper levels:

Level 1: Belief (What the flesh believes vs. what my new heart knows)

• What false belief does this passage expose in the flesh?
• What gospel truth replaces that lie?
• How will I meditate on and rehearse this truth until my thinking aligns with my new heart’s knowledge?

Level 2: Desire (What the flesh pursues vs. what my new heart treasures)

• What counterfeit is my flesh trusting for significance or security?
• How has the gospel exposed that counterfeit’s inability to satisfy?
• How can I actively turn from the counterfeit toward Christ—the One my new heart already loves?

Level 3: Dependence (Where I’m living independently vs. the dependence my new heart desires)

• Where is the flesh living independently, trusting my own resources?
• What would it look like to depend on God in this specific area—which is what my new heart actually wants?
• How can I practice gospel-dependence rather than self-sufficiency?

The difference: Behavior change flows from renewed beliefs and desires, not willpower. You’re not trying to change your heart (it’s already new). You’re cooperating with the Spirit to bring your thinking and choosing into alignment with your heart’s true direction.

Why This Works: The Power of Going Deeper

Surface-level application produces temporary change. Below-the-waterline transformation addresses what actually drives us. Here’s why it works:

It Addresses the Root, Not Just the Fruit

Behavior is fruit; the flesh’s beliefs and desires are part of the root. Pruning fruit doesn’t change the tree. When we address unconscious beliefs and functional idols, the behavior changes naturally as a result.

It Depends on the Spirit, Not Willpower

We can white-knuckle behavioral change for a season, but when willpower is exhausted, we default to what operates below the waterline. This method cooperates with the Spirit’s transforming work rather than depending on human effort.

It Applies the Gospel, Not Just Moral Commands

Behavioral checklists feel like law, not grace. They burden rather than free. When we see how Christ addresses our deepest longings better than any counterfeit, transformation flows from desire, not duty.

It Aligns with Your New Heart

If you’re in Christ, your heart already wants God. This method helps you align your thinking, choosing, and living with what your heart truly desires. The struggle isn’t between two corrupt hearts—it’s between your new heart and remaining flesh. And your new heart will win.

A Brief Example: Matthew 6:25-34 (Anxiety)

Let’s see how this works with a familiar passage on worry:

Step 1: Ask the Heart Question
What’s below the waterline? The passage reveals unconscious beliefs like “My security depends on having enough” and “God might not provide what I need.” The functional idol is control—trying to secure our future through worry and planning.

Step 2: Expose the Counterfeit
Anxiety is trusting our ability to control the future rather than trusting God’s provision. Jesus exposes the futility: worry can’t add a single hour to our lives. It promises security but delivers only fear.

Step 3: Embrace the Gospel
Jesus points to the Father’s care: He feeds birds, clothes grass, knows our needs. The gospel truth: You have a heavenly Father who values you and will provide what you need. Your worth to Him is established (you’re His child), and He’s trustworthy.

Step 4: Apply Below the Waterline

Belief: The flesh believes “I need financial security to be safe.” Gospel truth: “God is my security; He knows my needs and will provide.” Practice: When anxiety rises, rehearse God’s faithful provision in the past.

Desire: The flesh wants the security that control promises. My new heart knows Christ provides better security—unfailing, eternal, secure. Practice: When tempted to control, consciously turn toward trusting God’s provision.

Dependence: The flesh tries to secure the future independently through planning and worry. Practice: Make responsible plans, then consciously depend on God for the outcome rather than trusting my control.

The Spirit’s Essential Role

This method is not self-help or a technique for self-transformation. It’s a way of cooperating with the Holy Spirit’s transforming work.

The Spirit:

• Illuminates Scripture so we can understand its meaning (1 Corinthians 2:14)
• Applies truth to our specific circumstances (John 16:13)
• Transforms us into Christ’s image (2 Corinthians 3:18)

We cannot manufacture heart change through better methods or greater effort. We can only cooperate with what the Spirit is already doing, positioning ourselves to receive His transforming work.

Ready to Go Deeper?

The “Reading Below the Waterline” method addresses what traditional Bible study often misses: the unconscious beliefs, deep purposes, and functional idols that operate beneath conscious awareness.

You’ve learned:

• The iceberg principle (10% visible, 90% hidden)
• Biblical foundation (Proverbs 20:5 and the need to “draw out” deep purposes)
• The new heart reality (if you’re in Christ, your heart truly wants God)
• The four-step method (Heart Question, Expose Counterfeit, Embrace Gospel, Apply Below Waterline)
• Why it works (addresses root, depends on Spirit, applies gospel, aligns with new heart)

What’s next?

This landing page gives you the framework. But experiencing transformation requires practice. That’s why we’ve created a free 7-day email course that walks you through the method step-by-step with daily practice and real examples.

Get the Free 7-Day Email Course:

Learn to read the Bible for transformation, not just information. Over 7 days, you’ll:

• Practice all four steps with guided examples
• Experience at least one “aha” moment where you discover something below the waterline
• Develop a method you can use with any passage for the rest of your life
• Move beyond surface-level application to Spirit-empowered change

---

Related Resources:

• How to Study the Bible – Foundational principles of biblical interpretation
• Our Theological Framework – The gospel-centered foundation that shapes all our content
• Bible Studies – See the “Below the Waterline” approach in action

---

The “Reading Below the Waterline” method is rooted in Proverbs 20:5 and shaped by TGT’s gospel-centered theological framework. True transformation addresses what operates beneath conscious awareness, cooperating with the Spirit’s work to align our lives with the new heart we’ve been given in Christ.